The asking rent is only part of the story.
A commercial space may be advertised at $18 per square foot, but that does not necessarily mean the tenant’s occupancy cost is $18 per square foot. Property taxes, insurance, common-area maintenance, utilities and other expenses can materially change the numbers.
When I look at a commercial leasing opportunity, one of my first questions is simple: What does the quoted rental rate actually include?
Until that is clear, it is difficult to compare properties or properly evaluate the deal.
Commercial leases are governed largely by the agreement
Commercial leasing in Ontario is different from residential leasing.
The Ontario Commercial Tenancies Act applies to commercial landlord and tenant relationships and expressly excludes tenancies governed by the Residential Tenancies Act, 2006. Commercial lease disputes are not normally handled through the Landlord and Tenant Board, and the rules familiar to residential landlords and tenants should not be carried over into a commercial transaction.
There is also no single standard commercial lease that applies to every property. Ontario’s guidance for commercial tenants and landlords identifies matters such as rent, increases, deposits, insurance, maintenance, repairs, renewals and termination as items that should be addressed in the lease. It also cautions that the signed agreement may take precedence over provisions of the Commercial Tenancies Act in some circumstances.
That makes the wording of the lease extremely important.
Terms such as “gross,” “net” and “triple net” are useful descriptions, but they are not substitutes for reading the agreement. Two leases described as triple net can allocate costs differently. The exact definitions of base rent, additional rent, operating costs, taxes and the tenant’s proportionate share are what determine the financial obligation.
Base rent and additional rent
Most commercial lease calculations begin with two general categories.
Base rent, sometimes called minimum rent, is the amount paid for the tenant’s right to occupy the premises. It is commonly quoted as an annual amount per square foot.
For example:
- Premises: 2,000 square feet
- Base rent: $18 per square foot annually
- Annual base rent: 2,000 × $18 = $36,000
- Monthly base rent: $36,000 ÷ 12 = $3,000
That calculation is straightforward. What it does not tell us is whether the tenant must pay other property expenses.
Additional rent is a lease-defined category covering amounts payable in addition to base rent. Depending on the agreement, it may include property taxes, building insurance, maintenance, common-area costs, management or administration charges, utilities and other property-related expenses.
Many commercial leases state that additional rent is recoverable in the same manner as base rent. That is one reason tenants should not treat it as a loose estimate or an optional charge. The definition needs to be understood before the lease is signed.
I often see people focus heavily on negotiating one or two dollars off the base rent while spending much less time reviewing additional rent. In some properties, the additional rent deserves just as much attention as the base rate.
What is a gross lease?
Under a gross lease, the tenant generally pays one rental amount and the landlord pays most or all of the property’s operating expenses from that rent.
A true gross lease may include:
- Property taxes
- Building insurance
- Common-area maintenance
- Certain utilities
- General building operating costs
The tenant may still be responsible for its own business insurance, telephone, internet, cleaning inside the premises and other costs specifically assigned to it.
The main attraction for a tenant is predictability. A single rental amount is easier to budget than a base rent plus several changing expense categories.
For the landlord, a gross lease provides control over the operation of the property, but it also retains more expense risk. If taxes, insurance, snow removal, repairs or utilities rise faster than expected, the landlord may absorb the increase until the rent can be adjusted under the lease.
A landlord offering a gross rate therefore needs to price that risk into the rent. The lease should also be clear about whether the gross rent is fully inclusive or whether specific costs remain outside it.
The base-year variation
Some gross leases use a base year for operating expenses. The landlord pays expenses up to an agreed base-year amount, while the tenant pays its share of increases over that amount in later years.
This gives the tenant some initial predictability without requiring the landlord to absorb every future increase. The calculation still requires care, particularly if the lease allows adjustments to the base year or changes in how expenses are allocated.
What is a modified gross lease?
A modified gross lease falls somewhere between a fully gross lease and a net lease.
The rent includes certain property expenses, but other costs are paid separately by the tenant. For example, the landlord may include property taxes and building insurance in the rent while requiring the tenant to pay:
- Its own separately metered utilities
- Interior maintenance and repairs
- Waste removal
- HVAC maintenance
- A share of common-area costs
There is no universal modified gross formula. The term only tells me that expenses have been divided between the parties in some way.
The useful question is not, “Is this a modified gross lease?” It is, “Exactly which costs are included, and which costs remain the tenant’s responsibility?”
Modified gross leases can work well, particularly in smaller commercial buildings or where the parties want a practical division of responsibilities. They become difficult when the offer to lease and the final lease do not clearly identify that division.
What is a net lease?
Under a net lease, the tenant pays base rent plus some or all of the property’s operating expenses.
The base rent is intended primarily to compensate the landlord for the use of the space. Expenses allocated to the tenant are charged separately, generally as additional rent.
This structure protects the landlord from some increases in property-level costs. If municipal taxes or the building’s insurance premium rises, the tenant may bear its proportionate share rather than the landlord absorbing the increase.
For the tenant, a lower quoted base rent does not necessarily mean lower occupancy costs. The total depends on the additional rent and any costs paid directly by the tenant.
Single-net, double-net and triple-net leases
These descriptions are commonly used to indicate which expense categories have been transferred to the tenant:
- Under a single-net lease, the tenant generally pays base rent plus property taxes or a proportionate share of them.
- Under a double-net lease, the tenant generally pays base rent plus property taxes and building insurance.
- Under a triple-net lease, the tenant generally pays base rent plus property taxes, building insurance and maintenance or operating costs.
The labels are not always applied consistently in the Canadian market. In practice, many Ontario listings are simply described as “net” even where the tenant is responsible for the three main TMI categories.
A triple-net lease can also go beyond those three headings. Depending on the wording, the tenant may be responsible for utilities, repairs, HVAC service, waste removal, parking lot maintenance, snow removal, landscaping, management fees and other expenses.
That is why I would never rely on the label alone. The expense definitions and exclusions in the actual lease matter more.
TMI and common-area costs
TMI generally refers to:
- Taxes: Usually municipal property taxes and related property assessments allocated according to the lease.
- Maintenance: The costs of operating, repairing and maintaining the property and its common areas.
- Insurance: The landlord’s cost of insuring the building, again allocated as set out in the lease.
In a multi-tenant property, the tenant will commonly pay a proportionate share of these costs. That share may be based on the tenant’s rentable or leased area compared with the applicable area of the building or complex.
Common Area Maintenance, or CAM, generally refers to costs associated with shared areas and facilities. Depending on the property, these may include parking lots, driveways, hallways, lobbies, elevators, lighting, landscaping, snow clearing and common mechanical systems.
CAM and TMI are sometimes used interchangeably in conversation, but they are not necessarily identical. CAM may be one component within a broader additional-rent calculation.
The lease should establish:
- How the tenant’s proportionate share is determined
- Which areas are included in the calculation
- Which expenses are recoverable
- Whether any expense categories are capped
- Whether management or administration fees are added
- Whether costs are estimated and later reconciled
- Whether the tenant has review or audit rights
The calculation can become particularly important in a mixed-use property, a building with vacant space or a complex containing areas that serve only certain tenants.
A recent Ontario commercial lease decision discussed by Miller Thomson involved disputes over CAM charges, roof replacement and the calculation of rent. The court examined whether expenses fell within the lease wording and found problems with costs that had been charged outside the agreed CAM provisions. The case is a useful reminder that recoverability depends on the lease, not simply on whether the landlord incurred an expense.
Estimated additional rent and annual reconciliation
Additional rent is often collected using an estimated annual budget.
The landlord estimates taxes, insurance and operating costs for the coming year. The tenant pays its share monthly. After the year ends, the landlord compares the estimates with actual expenses and prepares a reconciliation.
If actual expenses were higher than estimated, the tenant may receive an invoice for the shortfall. If the tenant overpaid, the lease may require a credit or refund.
This system is normal, but tenants should understand the potential effect on cash flow. A monthly estimate of $10 per square foot can become $11.25 after reconciliation, depending on the actual costs and the lease calculation.
Before committing to a space, I would normally want to see:
- The current additional-rent estimate
- The prior year’s actual additional rent
- The operating budget, where available
- Any significant year-over-year changes
- The tenant’s proposed proportionate share
- The expenses specifically excluded from the calculation
For landlords, a clear reconciliation process is equally valuable. Proper budgets, consistent expense classifications and supporting records reduce misunderstandings and make annual adjustments easier to explain.
Capital expenditures and major building costs
Routine operating expenses are different from major capital expenditures, but leases do not always treat them in the same way.
A routine repair may be included in operating costs, while a major roof replacement, structural project or replacement of a substantial building system may be treated as a capital item. The lease may exclude capital expenditures, permit certain types of capital costs or allow an approved cost to be amortized over its useful life.
There is no safe assumption that every major cost belongs to the landlord or that every building-related cost can be passed through to the tenant. The answer depends heavily on the lease wording and the nature of the expenditure.
Both parties should pay attention to clauses dealing with:
- Structural repairs
- Roof and foundation work
- Replacement of major mechanical systems
- Capital improvements required by law
- Energy-saving projects
- Costs intended to reduce future operating expenses
- Amortization and financing charges
From a tenant’s perspective, an unlimited obligation for vaguely defined capital costs can create significant exposure. From a landlord’s perspective, an overly broad exclusion may prevent recovery of a project undertaken primarily to operate or preserve the property for tenant use.
This is an area where proper commercial leasing legal advice can be particularly valuable.
Comparing two hypothetical Ontario spaces
Consider two approximately 2,000-square-foot commercial spaces. These figures are illustrative only and exclude HST.
Space A: Modified gross lease
- Rent: $32 per square foot
- Annual rent: 2,000 × $32 = $64,000
- Estimated tenant-paid utilities: $6,000 annually
- Estimated annual occupancy cost: $70,000
- Estimated monthly cost: $5,833
Space B: Net lease
- Base rent: $18 per square foot
- Annual base rent: 2,000 × $18 = $36,000
- Additional rent/TMI: $14.50 per square foot
- Annual additional rent: 2,000 × $14.50 = $29,000
- Estimated tenant-paid utilities: $7,000 annually
- Estimated annual occupancy cost: $72,000
- Estimated monthly cost: $6,000
Space B is advertised at $18 per square foot, compared with $32 for Space A. Looking only at the advertised rate, Space B appears considerably less expensive.
Once additional rent and utilities are included, Space B is estimated to cost $2,000 more per year.
That does not automatically make Space A the better property. Space B may have better access, parking, visibility, loading, ceiling height or a layout that saves the tenant money on improvements. The point is that the two rental rates cannot be compared until they are put on the same basis.
A rental rate quoted at $18 per square foot does not tell me very much until I know what else the tenant is responsible for paying.
Commercial real property rentals are generally taxable supplies for GST/HST purposes, and the current HST rate for taxable supplies made in Ontario is 13%. The parties should confirm the applicable tax treatment with their legal or accounting advisers, particularly where the transaction or use is unusual.
What landlords should consider
A landlord’s lease structure affects both income predictability and risk.
A gross lease can produce stable billing and may be easier for tenants to understand, but the landlord retains more exposure to increases in taxes, insurance, maintenance and utilities.
A net lease transfers more of that expense risk to the tenant. It can also require more administration. The landlord needs reliable budgets, accurate allocation methods and proper year-end reconciliations.
Owners should also consider how the structure will appear in the market. A low net rate may attract attention, but sophisticated tenants will look at the total occupancy cost. Clear disclosure of current additional rent can create more confidence than an attractive base rate followed by poorly explained charges.
The lease should match the way the property is actually operated. A multi-tenant office building, a standalone industrial property and a neighbourhood retail plaza do not necessarily require the same division of expenses.
What tenants should ask before signing
Before comparing commercial properties, tenants should bring every proposal back to an estimated monthly and annual cost.
The following questions usually reveal more than the advertised rate:
- Is the quoted rate gross, modified gross or net?
- What is included in the rent?
- What is charged as additional rent?
- What was the property’s actual additional rent last year?
- How is my proportionate share calculated?
- Are management or administration fees added?
- Are utilities separately metered, allocated or included?
- Who maintains and replaces the HVAC equipment?
- Can capital expenditures be included in operating costs?
- Are any expense categories capped?
- Is there an annual reconciliation?
- Does the lease give me a right to review supporting statements or records?
- Is parking included or charged separately?
- What insurance must I carry?
- Does the rent increase during the term?
I would also look beyond rent. Leasehold improvements, fixturing periods, deposits, personal guarantees, repair obligations, permitted use, signage, parking, assignment rights and restoration obligations can have just as much financial impact as the face rate.
The lease structure should fit the property and the deal
Gross leases offer simplicity, but the landlord retains more operating-cost risk. Net leases give the landlord greater expense recovery, but the tenant assumes more variability. Modified gross leases can divide that risk in a practical way, provided the division is clearly written.
None of these structures is automatically better.
The right question is whether the financial arrangement is understood, properly documented and suitable for the property and the businesses involved.
For tenants, that means comparing the full cost of occupancy rather than the base rent alone. For landlords, it means using a lease structure that produces fair recovery of property expenses without creating avoidable confusion.
Commercial leases are long-term financial commitments. Before binding the parties, the offer, lease and cost assumptions should be reviewed together, with appropriate commercial real estate, legal and accounting advice where needed.
This information is intended to provide general commercial real estate insight. It is not legal, accounting or tax advice. Every commercial lease and property is different, and professional advice should be obtained for the specific transaction.


